Budget Hotels in Fire Island, New York

We could not find any hotels near for the dates you have selected.
  • Whitman Motor Lodge
    Customer Reviews
    Fabulous 102 reviews 8.7 USD Per night
    • Nearest Airport is Duncan Aviation 55.864 km away
    • Nearest Bus Station is Huntington Coach 2.466 km away
    • Nearest Rail Station is Metro North - Larchmont Train Station 32.411 km away
  • Homewood Suites by Hilton Long Island-Melville
    Fabulous 127 reviews 8.7 USD Per night
    View Details
    “Amazing hotel”“Very clean and tidy”“Wonderful rooms”
    8.8
    Excellent

    266 Worldwide guest reviews

    All Reviews - 8.8
    • All Reviews - 8.8
    • Business - 9.4
    • Couples - 8
    • Families - 8.4
    • Friends - 8.5
    • Solo - 6
    • Syria - 10
    • South Korea - 10
    • Puerto Rico - 10
    • Ireland - 10
    • U.s. Virgin Islands - 10
    • Cuba - 10

    Room

    9

    Cleanliness

    9.2

    Location

    9.1

    Service

    9

    Value

    8.4

    Overall

    8.8
    • Amazing hotel
    • Very clean and tidy
    • Wonderful rooms
    • Excellent service
    • Great value for money
    • Syria
      10/10
    • South Korea
      10/10
    • Puerto Rico
      10/10
    • Ireland
      10/10
    • U.s. Virgin Islands
      10/10
    • Cuba
      10/10
    • Nearest Airport is Duncan Aviation 52.546 km away
    • Nearest Bus Station is Huntington Coach 7.942 km away
    • Nearest Rail Station is Metro North - Larchmont Train Station 31.406 km away
  • Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
    Fabulous 70 reviews 8.7 USD Per night
  • Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex
    Fabulous 90 reviews 8.7 USD Per night
    View Details
    “Amazing hotel”“Very clean and tidy”“Wonderful rooms”
    8.8
    Excellent

    163 Worldwide guest reviews

    All Reviews - 8.8
    • All Reviews - 8.8
    • Business - 8
    • Couples - 9
    • Families - 8.8
    • Solo - 6
    • Uganda - 10
    • El Salvador - 10
    • Nicaragua - 10
    • United Kingdom - 9.6
    • China - 9.2
    • Peru - 9

    Room

    10

    Breakfast Area

    10

    Staff

    10

    Food & Drinks

    10
    • Amazing hotel
    • Very clean and tidy
    • Wonderful rooms
    • Excellent service
    • Very fair prices
    • Uganda
      10/10
    • El Salvador
      10/10
    • Nicaragua
      10/10
    • United Kingdom
      9.6/10
    • China
      9.2/10
    • Peru
      9/10
    • Nearest Airport is Duncan Aviation 73.601 km away
    • Nearest Bus Station is Baumann & Sons Buses 5.31 km away
    • Nearest Rail Station is LIRR - Massapequa Station 25.057 km away
  • Holiday Inn Express Stony Brook-Long Island
    Customer Reviews
    Fabulous 185 reviews 8.6 USD Per night
    View Details
    “Amazing hotel”“Very clean and tidy”“Wonderful rooms”
    8.5
    Excellent

    333 Worldwide guest reviews

    All Reviews - 8.5
    • All Reviews - 8.5
    • Business - 9.6
    • Couples - 10
    • Families - 8.5
    • Friends - 9
    • Solo - 8
    • French Southern Territories - 10
    • Niger - 10
    • Israel - 10
    • Australia - 10
    • Reunion - 10
    • Ecuador - 9.8

    Room

    8.7

    Cleanliness

    8.9

    Location

    9.5

    Service

    8.8

    Value

    8.5

    Overall

    8.5
    • Amazing hotel
    • Very clean and tidy
    • Wonderful rooms
    • Excellent service
    • Great value for money
    • French Southern Territories
      10/10
    • Niger
      10/10
    • Israel
      10/10
    • Australia
      10/10
    • Reunion
      10/10
    • Ecuador
      9.8/10
    • Nearest Airport is Atlantic Aviation 81.383 km away
    • Nearest Bus Station is Greely bus stop 3.721 km away
    • Nearest Rail Station is Metro North - Fairfield Train Station 31.367 km away
  • Comfort Inn Medford
    Customer Reviews
    Very good 300 reviews 8.5 USD Per night
    View Details
    “Very good hotel”“Very clean and tidy”“Wonderful rooms”
    8.1
    Excellent

    138 Worldwide guest reviews

    All Reviews - 8.1
    • All Reviews - 8.1
    • Couples - 5.3
    • Families - 8.7
    • Azerbaijan - 10
    • United Kingdom - 8
    • Belgium - 8
    • Spain - 7
    • United States - 6.3
    • Norway - 6

    Cleanliness

    10

    Room

    10

    Bathroom

    10

    Location

    10

    Swimming Pool

    10

    Bathtub

    10
    • Very good hotel
    • Very clean and tidy
    • Wonderful rooms
    • Good service
    • Value for money is okay
    • Azerbaijan
      10/10
    • United Kingdom
      8/10
    • Belgium
      8/10
    • Spain
      7/10
    • United States
      6.3/10
    • Norway
      6/10
    • Nearest Airport is Business Aircraft Center 73.866 km away
    • Nearest Bus Station is Towne Bus Corporation 4.373 km away
    • Nearest Rail Station is Metro North - Fairfield Train Station 41.87 km away
  • Jake's 58 Hotel & Casino
    Customer Reviews
    Very good 117 reviews 8 USD Per night
    View Details
    “Very good hotel”“Great value for money”“Cleanliness is top-notch”
    7.6
    Very Good

    1118 Worldwide guest reviews

    All Reviews - 7.6
    • All Reviews - 7.6
    • Business - 4.7
    • Couples - 7.8
    • Families - 6.6
    • Friends - 6.8
    • Solo - 7
    • Montenegro - 10
    • Bahamas - 10
    • Malaysia - 10
    • Romania - 9
    • Saint Helena - 8
    • Costa Rica - 8

    Beverages

    10

    Bathroom

    10

    Breakfast Area

    10

    Restaurant

    10

    Cleanliness

    10

    Facilities

    10
    • Very good hotel
    • Great value for money
    • Cleanliness is top-notch
    • Pretty good rooms
    • Good service
    • Montenegro
      10/10
    • Bahamas
      10/10
    • Malaysia
      10/10
    • Romania
      9/10
    • Saint Helena
      8/10
    • Costa Rica
      8/10
    • Nearest Airport is Duncan Aviation 75.529 km away
    • Nearest Bus Station is Baumann & Sons Buses 3.371 km away
    • Nearest Rail Station is LIRR - Massapequa Station 29.48 km away
  • Ramada Plaza by Wyndham Holtsville Long Island
    Pleasant 452 reviews 6.9 USD Per night
    View Details
    “Bad hotel”“Not cleaned thoroughly ”“Rooms are not nice”
    6.4
    Good

    785 Worldwide guest reviews

    All Reviews - 6.4
    • All Reviews - 6.4
    • Business - 6.3
    • Couples - 5.4
    • Families - 5.2
    • Friends - 4.3
    • Solo - 7.2
    • Reunion - 10
    • Paraguay - 10
    • Puerto Rico - 10
    • China - 8.6
    • Belgium - 8.3
    • U.s. Virgin Islands - 8

    Room

    6.3

    Cleanliness

    6.3

    Location

    7.7

    Service

    7.3

    Value

    6

    Overall

    6.3
    • Bad hotel
    • Not cleaned thoroughly
    • Rooms are not nice
    • Average service
    • Value for money is okay
    • Reunion
      10/10
    • Paraguay
      10/10
    • Puerto Rico
      10/10
    • China
      8.6/10
    • Belgium
      8.3/10
    • U.s. Virgin Islands
      8/10
    • Nearest Airport is Duncan Aviation 87.653 km away
    • Nearest Bus Station is Towne Bus Corporation 2.761 km away
    • Nearest Rail Station is Metro North - Fairfield Train Station 40.876 km away
  • Americas Best Value Inn Smithtown/Long Island
    Pleasant 74 reviews 6.9 USD Per night
    View Details
    “Bad hotel”“Miserable service”“Cleanliness is lacking”
    6.4
    Good

    86 Worldwide guest reviews

    All Reviews - 6.4
    • All Reviews - 6.4
    • Couples - 2
    • Finland - 10
    • Spain - 9
    • China - 8.3
    • Turks And Caicos Islands - 8
    • Brazil - 7.9
    • Russia - 7.5

    Room

    5.9

    Cleanliness

    5.9

    Service

    5.8

    Overall

    6.1
    • Bad hotel
    • Miserable service
    • Cleanliness is lacking
    • Rooms are okay
    • Finland
      10/10
    • Spain
      9/10
    • China
      8.3/10
    • Turks And Caicos Islands
      8/10
    • Brazil
      7.9/10
    • Russia
      7.5/10
    • Nearest Airport is Duncan Aviation 75.723 km away
    • Nearest Bus Station is Suffolk Transportation Service 7.165 km away
    • Nearest Rail Station is LIRR - Massapequa Station 32.199 km away
  • Extended Stay America - Long Island - Melville
    Pleasant 257 reviews 6.8 USD Per night
    View Details
    “Bad hotel”“Not cleaned thoroughly ”“Rooms are not nice”
    6.6
    Good

    349 Worldwide guest reviews

    All Reviews - 6.6
    • All Reviews - 6.6
    • Business - 7.6
    • Couples - 6
    • Families - 7
    • Friends - 7.3
    • Solo - 5.6
    • U.s. Virgin Islands - 10
    • Brazil - 10
    • China - 8.9
    • Sierra Leone - 8.3
    • Tonga - 8
    • India - 8

    Location

    10

    Cleanliness

    10

    Staff

    10

    Food & Drinks

    10
    • Bad hotel
    • Not cleaned thoroughly
    • Rooms are not nice
    • Overpriced
    • Miserable service
    • U.s. Virgin Islands
      10/10
    • Brazil
      10/10
    • China
      8.9/10
    • Sierra Leone
      8.3/10
    • Tonga
      8/10
    • India
      8/10
    • Nearest Airport is Duncan Aviation 54.22 km away
    • Nearest Bus Station is Baumann & Sons Buses 8.028 km away
    • Nearest Rail Station is Metro North - Larchmont Train Station 33.711 km away
  • Days Inn by Wyndham Long Island/Copiague
    Pleasant 202 reviews 6.7 USD Per night
    View Details
    “Bad hotel”“Rooms are not nice”“Miserable service”
    6.1
    Good

    221 Worldwide guest reviews

    All Reviews - 6.1
    • All Reviews - 6.1
    • Business - 3.5
    • Couples - 4.8
    • Families - 5.3
    • Solo - 5.5
    • Namibia - 10
    • Sierra Leone - 8
    • Georgia - 8
    • Sao Tome And Principe - 8
    • Dominican Republic - 7.1
    • Saint Helena - 7

    Room

    10

    Food & Drinks

    10

    Room Equipment

    10

    Bar

    10

    Smoke Smell

    0

    Smell

    0
    • Bad hotel
    • Rooms are not nice
    • Miserable service
    • The location is not great
    • Cleanliness is lacking
    • Value for money is okay
    • Namibia
      10/10
    • Sierra Leone
      8/10
    • Georgia
      8/10
    • Sao Tome And Principe
      8/10
    • Dominican Republic
      7.1/10
    • Saint Helena
      7/10
    • Nearest Airport is Duncan Aviation 58.608 km away
    • Nearest Bus Station is Baumann & Sons Buses 0.397 km away
    • Nearest Rail Station is LIRR - Massapequa Station 6.314 km away
  • Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island
    Pleasant 117 reviews 6.7 USD Per night
    View Details
    “Mediocre hotel”“Cleanliness is lacking”“Rooms are okay”
    6.1
    Good

    116 Worldwide guest reviews

    All Reviews - 6.1
    • All Reviews - 6.1
    • Business - 7
    • Couples - 5.3
    • Families - 5.8
    • Friends - 6
    • Solo - 5.1
    • United Kingdom - 10
    • Dominican Republic - 7.9
    • France - 7.1
    • Venezuela - 7
    • United States - 6.6
    • Belgium - 6.3

    Room

    6.1

    Cleanliness

    6.4

    Location

    7.9

    Service

    6.7

    Value

    5.6

    Overall

    6.1
    • Mediocre hotel
    • Cleanliness is lacking
    • Rooms are okay
    • Average service
    • Value for money is okay
    • United Kingdom
      10/10
    • Dominican Republic
      7.9/10
    • France
      7.1/10
    • Venezuela
      7/10
    • United States
      6.6/10
    • Belgium
      6.3/10
    • Nearest Airport is Duncan Aviation 71.124 km away
    • Nearest Bus Station is Baumann & Sons Buses 10.19 km away
    • Nearest Rail Station is LIRR - Massapequa Station 20.77 km away

Find Budget Hotels in Fire Island, New York with Triphobo

Travel like a real traveler. Grab your budget hotel in Fire Island by making a wise choice for your pocket. These budget hotels stick on to your planned costs and you will come back home not fretting over the expenses. Replete with all the basic amenities, these budget hotels won’t let you complain for anything. Don’t think you will have a limited choice. We have a range of hotels that will suit your pocket and your dream. We offer you some of the best budget hotels that suit your pocket like Whitman Motor Lodge and Courtyard by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex. Don’t let high costs suppress your will to travel. Book with us for affordable accommodations.