Best Things To Do in Shelter Island, New York

Whether you're visiting Shelter Island for a few days or are a localite, Shelter Island is sure to have something new for you. Explore our guide that tells you about the best tourist places to visit and things to do in Shelter Island. This guide will give you an idea about the popular attractions, upcoming tourist spots, and off-beat things to do in Shelter Island. This makes it easy to plan weekends or long vacations in Shelter Island. We have compiled this cool stuff to do in Shelter Island keeping in mind the points of interest for families, groups, and romantic couples. Looking at the activities for adventure junkies in Shelter Island listed here will get the blood rushing and adrenaline pumping through your veins.

Check out free places to visit in Shelter Island which you can visit without spending a penny. Handpicked tours, day trips, and excursions in Shelter Island will make your visit comfortable. You will also find the opening and closing time, along with the time required to cover major attractions. This will help you to have a flawless plan without much hassle. We have also included eateries in Shelter Island recommended by locals.

Tourist Attractions in Shelter Island

Take a look at these famous tourist attractions in Shelter Island that are a must-visit!

  1. #1 of 35 Things To Do in Shelter Island
    - Used in 14 itineraries
    Mashomack Preserve Image
    ©

    Tags: Park

    Address: 47 S Ferry Rd

    Google Reviews
    Ming Wu

    A fantastic day hike and nature retreat tucked away on Shelter Island. The Visitor Center volunteers/rangers are really friendly and helpful. We thoroughly enjoyed the Red & Yellow trail (3 mile loop)...

    Read more
  2. #2 of 35 Things To Do in Shelter Island
    - Used in 11 itineraries
    Shelter Island Presbyterian Image
    ©

    Tags: Church

    Address: 32 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA

    Google Reviews
    Harry Biddle

    Nice place, with pretty acoustics. If you can, go to the Juniata College Concert Choir performance in the early spring. It is a special afternoon of music.

    Read more
  3. #3 of 35 Things To Do in Shelter Island
    - Used in 5 itineraries
    Shelter Island Historical Society Image
    ©

    Address: 16 S Ferry Rd, P.O. Box 847

    Timings: 10:00 am - 02:00 pm Details
    Google Reviews
    Florence Hosp

    They are building and renovating the house and vault. There will be meeting and show rooms. Outstanding!!! Thank you for all the good work.

    Read more
  4. #4 of 35 Things To Do in Shelter Island
    - Used in 6 itineraries
    Coecles Harbor Marina & Boatyard Image
    ©

    Address: 18 Hudson Ave

    Timings: 08:00 am - 04:30 pm Details
    Google Reviews
    Pierrick Chouard

    Very friendly staff. Great facilities. Very well sheltered. Reasonable prices

    Read more
  5. #5 of 35 Things To Do in Shelter Island
    - Used in 7 itineraries
    Shelter Island Public Library Image
    ©

    Address: North Ferry Road, P.O. Box 2016

    Timings: 09:30 am - 05:00 pm Details
    Google Reviews
    Jeremy And Unknown Savage Gaming

    This is my favorite place to play on the laptops and do fun activities!

    Read more
  6. #6 of 35 Things To Do in Shelter Island
    - Used in 10 itineraries
    Saint Mary's Episcopal Church Image
    ©

    Tags: Church

    Address: 26 St Mary's Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA

  7. #7 of 35 Things To Do in Shelter Island
    - Used in 6 itineraries
    South Ferry Image
    ©

    Address: 135 S Ferry Rd, P.O. Box 2024

    Timings: 09:00 am - 05:00 pm Details
  8. #8 of 35 Things To Do in Shelter Island
    - Used in 4 itineraries
    Wades Beach Image
    ©

    Address: 114 S Midway Rd

    Timings: 09:00 am - 05:00 pm Details
  9. #9 of 35 Things To Do in Shelter Island
    - Used in 6 itineraries

Find more attractions and things to do in Shelter Island under these categories.